Newest Recipe Testing! – Sally’s Baking Habit
6 min read
Welcome to a different rendition of my Newest Recipe Testing collection!
By no means have I been within the kitchen a lot, so typically, and with so many flops. It’s a numbers sport. I’m presently testing recipes for proper now, for the vacation baking season, and for my cookbook. So, I’m sure to have extra recipe disasters, proper?

Over the previous a number of years, as the vacation baking season turns into increasingly more outstanding on my web site, I’ve discovered that I gained’t have the ability to sustain until I’ve a inventory of content material able to go. My web site sees probably the most web site site visitors from September via December, and I need to make the most of the need for fall and vacation baking! Final 12 months I printed about 30 brand-new recipes throughout that point, and I plan for a similar quantity of content material this 12 months.
I have already got 4 accomplished!
So proper now, my workforce and I are balancing recipes for 3 totally different time frames. It’s been laborious to mentally set up when leaping between adorning Valentine’s Day cookies for now, photographing pies for Pie Week later within the 12 months, and growing new recipes for my cookbook, which gained’t come out till 2024 or 2025.
We dedicate 1 week per thirty days to every of the three. That’s one of the simplest ways I’ve discovered to compartmentalize all this content material!
Bran Muffins That Don’t Style Like Cardboard
One of many first initiatives I labored on this 12 months was my recipe for wholesome bran muffins. I performed round with the quantity of wheat bran, flour, and liquid a couple of instances till I reached a pleasant stability of hearty and smooth, with out tasting like cardboard. (At all times a pleasant bonus.)

One of many take a look at batches was tasty, however the batter was fairly skinny and the ensuing muffins had been squat and greasy. Including a bit of extra flour bulked up the batter, and the ultimate batch was successful.
Saucy Blueberry Sauce & Lemon Cheesecake
The primary picture on this put up is my blueberry sauce topping. This one didn’t want an excessive amount of testing, as I used the swirl from this blueberry swirl cheesecake and topping from this blueberry cream cheese pie as my start line. I added significantly extra water so the sauce is, properly, saucy. 😉
I even have a brand new recipe for lemon cheesecake on my web site. For this recipe, I used my key lime cheesecake as the bottom, and infused the sugar with lemon zest for further taste. This was straightforward to check as properly—I like making cheesecake.

The Unimaginable Shrinking Cake
I developed this chocolate raspberry cake primarily for the raspberry filling, by well-liked demand. Through the years I’ve acquired a lot of requests for a raspberry cake filling recipe, and now the reply is… sure, I’ve one!!


I based mostly the chocolate cake batter on this recipe for darkish chocolate peanut butter cake, however by chance used 8-inch pans as a substitute of 9-inch pans. Whereas this often isn’t an enormous deal—simply want to regulate the bake time—I really overfilled the 8-inch pans, which did nothing in my favor. The cake layers baked up within the strangest manner and regarded like brains. Completely unintentional, however perhaps I’m onto one thing for Halloween? LOL.

The muffins rose up, sank down within the facilities, and completed with unhappy crinkle-wrinkle facilities. The lesson right here is: don’t overfill your cake pans, and use the really useful cake pan dimension.
Baking does require utilizing your mind (particularly when doing the maths for cake pan sizes and conversions!), however muffins that look like brains had been undoubtedly not what I used to be going for.
Nice information… you’ll be able to bake a non-brain cake by following my chocolate raspberry cake recipe. 😉
Strawberry Cream-Crammed Chocolate Cupcakes
My recipe for chocolate-covered strawberry cupcakes was initially printed in 2018. I lately modified the chocolate cupcake batter so it matches my cream-filled chocolate cupcakes. (That are fairly probably the very best cupcakes I’ve ever made, and I stand agency on that.) The up to date batter merely bakes up stronger, and holds the strawberry buttercream a bit of higher. They’re deeply chocolatey and further moist. Like Hostess cupcakes, with a strawberry twist.

Should you cherished the previous model, the batter matched these chocolate cupcakes!
Getting a Head Begin on Sally’s Cookie Palooza 2023
I’m actually excited to publish a recipe for gingerbread cookie bars later this 12 months. My first batch was supremely flavorful and spiced (simply what I wished!), however the texture was utterly off. They had been fluffy and cake-like, as when you had been consuming a heavy sq. of gingerbread cake:

I had a superb feeling concerning the cookie dough, although. It’s just like my chewy chocolate chip cookies, and so I made a decision to scale back the flour and bake the dough in a bigger pan. The bars had been thinner, which made them flatter and chewier. That is simply what I wished: dense, chewy, moist, spiced, excellent.
That recipe is coming in December. Advised you I used to be getting forward!
Nonetheless on a ginger molasses kick, I made a decision to bake a batch of those white chocolate chip molasses cookies in hopes to replace the pictures. Nicely, I forgot to set the oven timer, took a cellphone name, forgot they had been within the oven, turned the oven off, then 2 hours later preheated the oven for one thing else.
As my assistant, Beth, and I went to place some bread within the oven, we discovered a baking sheet of lumpy hockey pucks. The cookies baked as meant, after which continued their oven journey because the oven cooled down, and preheated once more. I’m unhappy to report that they didn’t survive the whirlwind journey.

Oven timers… time and time once more… show to be helpful. 😉
Q: Have you ever had a recipe fail currently?
Cookbook Sneak Peek
My subsequent cookbook is properly underway, and it’s untitled in the meanwhile! This baking cookbook will probably be my largest but. 100 baking recipes divided amongst chapters together with yeast bread, breakfast, cookies, muffins, fast breads, cupcakes, and extra. The ebook will probably be principally new and unique recipes to the ebook, and also will embrace a handful of the most well-liked recipes on my web site. It is going to be good to have them professionally printed in a tangible ebook!
My manuscript deadline is a 12 months away, after which the ebook will proceed within the modifying and design phases earlier than heading to print. Thanks upfront on your endurance. That is the primary time I’ve written such a big manuscript, whereas concurrently managing workers, working a big web site, and elevating youngsters!
And looking for time to relaxation and recharge so my inventive juices proceed to movement!
The most recent cookbook recipe I examined was a spin on my buttermilk biscuits. Suppose bacon, spicy honey, cheddar cheese, and chives. My knees really went weak on the first style. And also you’ll get pleasure from recipes for smooth jalapeño bread, deeply chocolate cheesecake, one other recipe for chewy molasses cookies (I’m on a kick!), and you may guess these well-liked banana muffins will make an look. I can’t wait to share extra with you! Keep tuned.